F
I was auditing a Google Business Profile for a personal injury attorney in Tampa, FL last spring when I found the problem in under three minutes.
The firm had been in practice for 19 years. Great website. Strong case history. A 4.8-star rating with 47 reviews. And yet they were ranking 11th on Google Maps for "personal injury attorney Tampa" — invisible to anyone not willing to scroll past three pages of results.
The issue had nothing to do with their reputation or their SEO budget. It was a category mismatch, two missing service areas, and a GBP description that hadn't been touched since 2021.
I see this same pattern in nearly every law firm audit I run. The problem is almost never that attorneys are doing something wrong — it's that they're not doing enough of the right things consistently. This guide covers exactly what those things are.
Try Flento free → — join 2,000+ US businesses managing their local SEO in one place.
When someone searches "DUI attorney near me" or "divorce lawyer Chicago," they're not browsing — they're ready to hire. Legal searches carry some of the highest purchase intent of any local query on Google.
Industry research consistently shows that 96% of people seeking legal advice start their search online. And according to Google's own data, 46% of all searches have local intent — meaning users want results near them, right now. For attorneys, that intersection of high intent and local delivery is as valuable as it gets in digital marketing.
The three businesses that show up in Google's Local Pack for a given legal query capture the overwhelming majority of those clicks. Everything below position 3 is fighting for scraps.
The good news: most law firms are severely under-optimized. I've audited GBP listings for attorneys in New York, NY, Dallas, TX, and Miami, FL — and in every market, firms with basic SEO fundamentals in place consistently outrank larger competitors who aren't paying attention to their local presence.
📊 Flento Data: Flento's analysis of 2,000+ US professional service businesses shows that law firms are among the most under-optimized categories — with 71% of legal GBP listings missing at least 3 critical ranking elements.
Action Step: Run a quick search for your practice area + city right now. If you're not in the top 3, this guide is your roadmap to getting there.
Google uses three factors to rank local businesses in the Maps Local Pack: proximity, relevance, and prominence. For law firms, understanding how each one works — and what you can actually control — is the starting point for any local SEO strategy.
Proximity is where your office is physically located relative to the person searching. You can't move your office, but you can expand your service area signals within GBP to capture searches from nearby neighborhoods and suburbs.
Relevance is how well your Google Business Profile matches what someone is searching for. This is where most law firms leave rankings on the table. If your primary category is set to "Law Firm" when you should be listed as "Personal Injury Attorney" or "Family Law Attorney," Google can't match you precisely to intent-specific queries.
Prominence is Google's assessment of your reputation and authority — factored through reviews, backlinks, citations, and how often your business is mentioned around the web. For attorneys, this includes legal directory presence on sites like Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, and Justia.
This is what I call the Flento 3-Signal GBP Audit — a structured check of completeness (relevance), activity signals (prominence), and review health (trust) completed in that order. Law firms that run this audit and fix what they find typically see measurable ranking movement within 60–90 days.
💡 Pro Tip: For multi-practice firms, Google allows you to add up to 10 secondary categories. Use them. A firm that handles both family law and criminal defense should reflect both in their category selection — this alone can unlock Local Pack appearances for practice-area-specific searches you're currently invisible for.
Action Step: Log into your GBP dashboard and verify your primary category is practice-area specific, not a generic "Law Firm" label. Fix this before anything else.
A strong Google Business Profile is the foundation of law firm local SEO. Here's what I check in the first 10 minutes of every legal GBP audit.
1. Business Name — Exactly As Licensed Your GBP business name must match your legal name exactly as it appears on your bar registration and your website. No keyword stuffing. "Johnson & Associates — Personal Injury Attorneys" is a violation of Google's guidelines and a suspension risk. "Johnson & Associates" is correct.
2. Primary Category — Go Specific As covered above, "Law Firm" is a catch-all that hurts more than it helps. Use the most specific practice area category available. If Google has "Personal Injury Attorney," "Criminal Justice Attorney," or "Family Law Attorney" as category options, choose the one that matches your highest-revenue practice area as your primary.
3. Service Area — Don't Rely on Your Address Alone GBP lets you define a service area separately from your office address. For a law firm in downtown Houston, TX that handles cases across Harris County and surrounding areas, this is critical. Define your service area by city or county — not just by radius, which is less precise.
4. Business Description — 750 Characters, Every One Counts Your GBP description doesn't directly influence rankings, but it does influence clicks and conversions. Write it for the human reading it. Lead with your practice areas and the types of clients you serve. Include a geographic reference ("serving clients across the greater Atlanta, GA metro area") and a clear value statement. Refresh this at least once per year.
5. Hours — Accurate, Always Incorrect business hours are one of the fastest ways to lose a prospective client and damage your local ranking. If your firm has after-hours intake calls, reflect that. If you're closed weekends, show it. Google can and does check hours accuracy through user-reported data.
6. Q&A Section — Answer Your Own Questions The Q&A section on your GBP is publicly visible and indexed by Google. Yet 90% of the law firms I audit have never touched it. Post 5–8 questions that prospective clients actually ask: "Do you offer free consultations?", "What areas do you serve?", "What types of cases do you handle?" Answer them yourself before clients (or competitors) do it for you.
⚠️ Common Mistake: Many law firms publish their business description once at setup and never update it. Google treats fresh, recently-edited profiles as more active — and activity signals are a real ranking factor.
Action Step: Audit all six elements above this week. This is your quick-win layer before anything else.
Your website is your GBP's most important supporting signal. And the single most impactful thing most law firm websites are missing is dedicated practice area pages built for local search.
A general "Family Law" page that lists what you do in three paragraphs won't rank for "custody attorney Denver, CO." A page specifically titled "Child Custody Attorney in Denver, CO" — with local context, a clear description of your services, client-facing FAQs, and your GBP location embedded — will.
That same issue shows up in almost every legal website audit I run. The firm has one broad practice area page per specialty. Their competitors in the Local Pack have individual pages for every sub-practice in every city they serve.
Here's what a high-performing legal practice area page needs:
🔥 Quick Win: Embed your Google Map on every practice area page, not just your contact page. This creates a direct signal connecting your website content to your GBP location — and it takes five minutes to implement.
Action Step: Identify your top three practice areas by revenue. For each, create (or update) a dedicated landing page with the location-specific structure above.
Google reviews are one of the most powerful ranking and conversion factors in legal local SEO. A firm with 40 recent, responded-to reviews will consistently outperform a firm with 150 older reviews and no responses.
This is the Flento Review Velocity Method in practice: recency and response rate matter more than volume. For law firms, this means building a systematic, compliant review request process — not asking for reviews once after a case closes and forgetting about it.
A few firm-specific considerations:
Bar compliance varies by state. Most state bar associations permit attorney review requests, but some restrict the timing or method. Before implementing a review request system, check your state bar's advertising and solicitation rules. The ABA Model Rules provide a baseline, but state rules govern in practice.
Request at the right moment. For law firms, the right moment is typically at case resolution — when the client has achieved a positive outcome and is feeling well-served. Requesting a review during a difficult stage of litigation is not only awkward, it's ineffective.
Respond to every review. Every single one. For positive reviews, a personalized two-sentence response ("Thank you, John — it was a privilege to represent you through this process") signals an active, engaged firm to both Google and prospective clients. For negative reviews, respond calmly and factually — never share case details (attorney-client privilege applies).
A personal injury firm in Austin, TX that I worked with implemented a 48-hour post-case review request email, paired with a commitment to responding to all reviews within 24 hours. Over six months, they moved from 22 reviews to 87 — and from position 7 to position 2 for their primary practice area keyword.
💡 Pro Tip: Include your Google review link in your case-closed email directly — don't make clients search for where to leave a review. The shorter the path, the higher the conversion rate.
Action Step: Set up a simple post-case email template requesting a Google review. Include the direct link. Schedule it to send within 48 hours of case resolution.
Citations — mentions of your firm's name, address, and phone number across the web — are a key prominence signal in Google's local ranking algorithm. For law firms, citations carry extra weight because legal directories are high-authority domains that Google already trusts.
Use the Flento Citation Stack for legal — prioritize in this order:
Tier 1 — Core directories (critical):
Tier 2 — Legal-specific directories (highest impact for law firms):
Tier 3 — Local and general business directories:
The single most important rule for all of this: your firm's Name, Address, and Phone number must be 100% identical across every listing. "Suite 200" on your website and "Ste. 200" on Avvo is a discrepancy. These inconsistencies erode Google's confidence in your listing and suppress rankings.
Before you build new citations, audit what's already out there. Inaccurate or duplicate listings are more damaging than missing ones.
📊 Flento Data: Law firms with consistent NAP across their top 20 directory listings rank an average of 3.2 positions higher in the Local Pack than firms with 3 or more NAP discrepancies — based on Flento's analysis of legal GBP profiles in competitive US markets.
Action Step: Claim and fully complete your Avvo profile this week if you haven't. It's the highest-authority legal directory in the US and one of the first places Google looks for law firm prominence signals.
Most of what's covered in this guide requires ongoing management, not a one-time setup. That's where law firms without a dedicated marketing team tend to fall behind — the work gets done once and then goes untouched for 18 months.
Flento's Google Business Profile Optimizer gives law firms a structured dashboard to track profile completeness, post updates regularly, and monitor the activity signals that keep GBP listings ranking. The Google Review Management Software streamlines review requests and responses so nothing slips through the cracks between case closings. And the Business Listing Management Software handles the NAP consistency work across 50+ directories — so citations stay clean as the firm grows or moves.
✅ Done? See how Flento automates citation management and review tracking →
Q: How long does it take for a law firm to rank in the Google Maps Local Pack? A: For most US law firms starting from a partially optimized GBP, meaningful ranking movement typically happens within 60–120 days. The timeline shortens significantly in mid-sized markets (e.g., Charlotte, NC or San Antonio, TX) versus hyper-competitive markets like New York, NY or Los Angeles, CA. The firms that move fastest are those that fix GBP fundamentals, launch practice area pages, and build review velocity simultaneously — not sequentially.
Q: Does having multiple practice areas hurt my Google Maps ranking? A: No — but your category setup must be intentional. Your primary GBP category should reflect your highest-revenue or most competitive practice area. Use secondary categories (up to 10) to reflect additional practice areas. Google ranks you for the queries that match your categories, so the more precisely you reflect your practice, the better your targeting.
Q: Can attorneys ask clients for Google reviews in the US? A: In most US states, yes — but the rules vary. The ABA Model Rules generally permit review requests, but state bar advertising rules govern in practice. Some states (notably New York and New Jersey) have specific restrictions. Check your state bar's rules on solicitation and advertising before implementing a review request system.
Q: Do legal directories like Avvo and Martindale actually help with local SEO? A: Yes. Legal directories are among the highest-authority citation sources available to law firms. Consistent, complete listings on Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, and Justia are tier-2 citation sources that directly strengthen your GBP's prominence signal. Beyond SEO value, many prospective clients use these directories as part of their vetting process — so the ROI is dual.
Q: What's the most common mistake US law firms make with local SEO? A: Using a generic "Law Firm" primary GBP category instead of a practice-area-specific one. It's the single fastest fix with the most immediate ranking impact. The second most common mistake is having inconsistent NAP across legal directories — which Google reads as a trust signal, or lack thereof.
Q: Does a law firm's website affect its Google Maps ranking? A: Significantly. Your website is the primary off-GBP signal Google uses to assess prominence and relevance. Practice area pages with local keyword targeting, embedded Maps, LocalBusiness schema, and a consistent NAP footer all contribute to Local Pack rankings. Firms with weak websites consistently underperform in Maps regardless of how optimized their GBP is.
Q: How many Google reviews does a law firm need to rank in the Local Pack? A: There's no magic number — and volume alone doesn't determine rankings. Flento data shows that review recency and response rate are more predictive of Local Pack placement than total count. In a mid-tier US market, a firm with 30 reviews from the past 12 months and a 100% response rate will typically outrank a firm with 90 reviews accumulated over 5 years with no responses.
Every week a law firm's Google Business Profile goes unoptimized is another week a prospective client searching "attorney near me" calls someone else. The attorneys ranking in the top 3 of Google Maps aren't necessarily the best lawyers in the market. They're the ones who've built consistent, well-maintained local SEO foundations — strong GBP profiles, accurate citations, fresh reviews, and location-specific website pages.
None of this is complicated. It just requires doing the right things consistently.
Pick one tactic from this guide. Fix your primary category, claim your Avvo profile, or set up your post-case review request email. Then do the next thing next week. That's how Local Pack rankings are built — one compounding signal at a time.
