Which one actually drives local customers? A side-by-side look at reach, control, and search visibility, plus how to use both platforms together.
Most local businesses treat their Facebook Business Page and Google Business Profile as two separate marketing chores. Set them both up, post on both, and hope something works. The businesses that actually get results understand exactly what each platform is for, and focus their energy accordingly.
Here's the short version: Google Business Profile drives the most local customer acquisition for most businesses. Facebook Business Page drives community engagement and brand recognition. They serve different moments in the customer journey, and conflating them leads to mediocre performance on both.
The same local search tactics apply to other verticals, including TikTok for local businesses.
It also helps to know how to add social profiles to your GBP, which we cover in a separate guide.
Google Business Profile is primarily a search discovery and maps tool. When someone searches "HVAC company near me" or "best Italian restaurant Nashville," your GBP is what determines whether they find you and whether they call. It's active intent, the customer is looking for something right now.
Facebook Business Page is primarily a community and relationship platform. People don't typically open Facebook to search for a plumber. They open Facebook to connect with businesses they already know, see what local businesses are doing, check event announcements, and sometimes discover new businesses through friends' shares or recommendations.
Both platforms matter. They serve different buyer moments. Understanding the difference prevents the common mistake of optimizing Facebook for search discovery (it won't beat Google) or treating GBP as a social media posting channel (it won't build community).
📊 Flento Data: Among local businesses analyzed, 78% cited Google Business Profile as their primary source of new customer inquiries from digital channels. Facebook Business Page ranked second but at a significantly lower rate, typically for businesses in categories with strong community identity (restaurants, gyms, retail).
A related read on reputation is Trustpilot vs Google Reviews.
If you want to go deeper, our article on Meta AI local search walks through how Meta AI recommends local businesses.
Google Business Profile wins this category decisively.
GBP is a confirmed local ranking signal. Google uses your GBP information, categories, description, reviews, activity signals, proximity, to determine where you rank in the Local Pack and Google Maps. This directly affects whether new customers find you when searching with purchase intent.
Facebook Business Page is a citation source. Your Facebook page provides a NAP (Name, Address, Phone) citation that contributes to Google's confidence in your business information, but it has no direct relationship with your Maps ranking. Facebook does not have a ranking impact equivalent to GBP.
In terms of pure local SEO leverage, every hour spent optimizing your GBP (updating categories, generating reviews, posting updates, completing your profile) produces more measurable local search impact than the same hour spent on your Facebook page.
⚠️ Common Mistake: Spending equal time on Facebook and GBP optimization assuming they have similar local SEO impact. For the Local Pack and Maps ranking, GBP optimization returns significantly more per hour invested.
There's a dedicated breakdown in Nextdoor for local businesses.
Related reading: our guide to branded search covers how brand searches and brand signals support local rankings.
Google Business Profile wins for active intent searches.
When someone is actively looking for a business type, searching with intent to purchase or visit, they use Google Maps and Search. GBP determines your visibility in those moments. A restaurant with a well-optimized GBP will be found by people searching "Italian restaurant near me" who have never heard of that restaurant before.
Facebook Business Page wins for passive discovery and community.
People discover businesses on Facebook through shared posts, tagged check-ins, event recommendations, and local group mentions. This is passive discovery, the customer wasn't looking for your business but encountered it through their social network. For businesses where word-of-mouth and community reputation drive growth (restaurants, local shops, gyms), Facebook's discovery mechanism has real value.
Voice search and AI assistants also increasingly pull from Google data. When someone asks their phone "find a dentist near me," that result comes from GBP, not Facebook.
💡 Pro Tip: Facebook is particularly valuable for businesses whose core marketing channel is community word-of-mouth, neighborhood restaurants, local boutiques, gyms, and studios. For emergency or high-intent service businesses (plumbers, electricians, locksmiths), active intent search on Google is the primary acquisition channel and Facebook plays a secondary role.
This connects well with performance max local businesses.
Google Reviews win for local SEO rankings.
Google Reviews are a direct local ranking factor. Review count, recency, response rate, and review content all influence where you appear in the Local Pack. A business with 50 active Google reviews will consistently outperform one with 10 in competitive local searches.
Facebook Reviews carry social proof value but not ranking impact.
Facebook reviews (now called "Recommendations") appear on your Facebook Business Page and can show up in branded search results. They build trust for people who research you on Facebook, but they don't affect your Google Maps ranking.
The Review Velocity Method, tracking recency and response rate, applies to Google Reviews. For Facebook, engagement (responses to recommendations, replies to comments) builds community trust but doesn't create a local SEO ranking signal.
🛠️ Action Step: Before spending time generating Facebook Recommendations, check your Google review count and last 90 days of review activity. If you have fewer than 25 recent Google reviews, every review effort should go to Google first.
| Feature | Google Business Profile | Facebook Business Page |
|---|---|---|
| Local Pack ranking signal | Yes (primary) | No |
| Appears in Google Maps | Yes | No |
| Review-based ranking signal | Yes | No |
| Citation value | Yes (primary) | Yes (secondary) |
| Organic search visibility | Yes | Yes (branded searches) |
| Social engagement features | Limited (posts, Q&A) | Full social platform |
| Event promotion | Limited | Yes (Events feature) |
| Community building | No | Yes |
| Paid advertising integration | Google Ads (separately) | Facebook/Instagram Ads |
| Customer messaging | Yes (GBP Messages) | Yes (Messenger) |
| Photos and videos | Yes | Yes |
| Free to use | Yes | Yes |
| Voice search integration | Yes (primary) | No |
| AI Overview citations | Yes (frequently) | No |
The most effective local businesses use both platforms in a coordinated way:
GBP is your primary local acquisition channel. Optimize it, maintain it, generate reviews on it, and post to it consistently. This is where new customers find you.
Facebook is your community retention channel. Engage existing customers, announce events and promotions, share behind-the-scenes content, and build the community identity that makes customers loyal and likely to recommend you.
Your Facebook Business Page is a citation that reinforces your GBP. Consistent NAP across both platforms (and everywhere else) strengthens Google's confidence in your location data.
Use GBP posts for local search signals (activity-based ranking signals). Use Facebook posts for community engagement (relationship-based retention). These serve different audiences in different moments.
💡 Pro Tip: Cross-post strategically. A great before/after photo from a recent job is worth posting to both GBP (as an activity signal) and Facebook (as community social proof). Create once, post both, don't choose between them when the content serves both purposes.
For new or newly optimized businesses: GBP first, always. Get your profile complete, get your categories right, get your reviews moving. Nothing in local marketing has a higher ROI than a properly optimized GBP for a business with weak local search visibility.
For established businesses with strong GBP: Add Facebook as a secondary channel for community engagement, event promotion, and brand building. The marginal value of additional GBP optimization decreases as your profile matures; the marginal value of Facebook engagement increases as your customer community grows.
Category-specific considerations:
Flento's Business Listing Management Software audits NAP consistency across both Google Business Profile and Facebook Business Page in the same scan, ensuring the address, phone number, and business name that Google sees on Facebook matches your GBP exactly.
The review management system tracks Google reviews as your primary metric (because that's what affects rankings) while also monitoring Facebook Recommendations so you have a complete view of your reputation across both platforms.
✅ Done? Track both platforms in one dashboard with Flento → [Try Flento free]
Does having a Facebook Business Page help my Google Maps ranking? Indirectly, as a citation source. Your Facebook page's consistent NAP contributes to Google's confidence in your business location data. It does not directly affect your Local Pack ranking the way GBP optimization does.
Should I post to both GBP and Facebook? Yes, but with different strategies. GBP posts signal active listing management to Google. Facebook posts build community engagement with existing customers. The content and purpose are different even when the subject is the same.
Which platform should I ask customers to review on? Google first. Google reviews are a local ranking signal; Facebook Recommendations are not. Once you have 25+ recent Google reviews with active responses, adding Facebook as a secondary review channel makes sense.
Can Facebook Recommendations appear in Google search results? Sometimes, for branded searches. If someone searches "[Your Business Name] reviews," your Facebook page with recommendations may appear. For local service searches, Google reviews (not Facebook) dominate the results.
Is it better to run Facebook Ads or Google Ads for local businesses? They serve different intent levels. Google Ads (including Local Services Ads) capture active intent, people searching for your service type right now. Facebook Ads build awareness with a targeted audience that isn't actively searching. Most local businesses with limited budgets get better immediate ROI from Google Ads; Facebook Ads work better when brand awareness is the goal.
